Cheapest on the menu · $3 Dirty Water Seltzer
Jake's Dilemma
Sports barUpper West Side430 Amsterdam Ave
4.0 ★ on Google, 1,532 reviews
Drink prices at Jake's Dilemma
No happy hour at Jake's Dilemma, as far as we can find. Beer is $3, wine $10, cocktails $11, off the regular menu, last checked July 27, 2026.
Seltzers & Teas
Dirty Water SeltzerCheapest pour$3
Bud Light Seltzer$5
NUTRL Vodka Seltzer$7
Spiked Ade$8
White Claw$10
Sun Cruiser Pink Lemonade$10
Sun Cruiser Iced Tea Vodka$10
High Noon$12
Surfside Peach Iced Tea$12
Surfside Vodka Iced Tea Lemonade$12
Draft
Heineken$5
Bud Light$8
Michelob Ultra$8
Coors Light$8
Angry Orchard Cider$9
Shock Top$9
Coney Island IPA$9
Kona Big Wave$9
Modelo$9
Sam Adams Seasonal$9
Landshark$9
Stella Artois$9
Goose Island Hazy IPA$9
Guinness$9
Six Point Crisp$9
Yuengling$9
Bottles
Heineken Silver$5
Corona$6
Becks$8
Coors Light$8
Brooklyn Lager$8
Bud$8
Bud Light$8
Corona Light$8
Pacifico$8
Peroni$8
Allagash White$8
Blue Moon$8
Lagunitas IPA$8
Brooklyn Summer$8
Cans
Miller Lite$5
Michelob Ultra$6
Austin Original Cider$8
Austin Pineapple Cider$8
Blue Point Illusion$8
Dog Fish Grateful Dead Juicy Pale Ale$8
Ball Lightning Pilsner$8
Narragansett Lager$8
Narragansett Shandy$8
Sierra Nevada Summerfest$8
House Wine$10
Trebbiano (White)
Sangiovese (Red)
Cocktails
Old No. 7 & Cola$11
Red Bull White Peach Spritz$14
The Amante Spritz$14
Espresso Martini$14
Tito's & Red Bull$15
Old Fashioned$15
Rum Haven Coconut Rum$15
Negroni$19
Premium Wine$12
Placido Pinot Grigio
Natura Sauvignon Blanc
Bigfoot Rose
Pinot Noir
Rose
Prices from Jake's Dilemma's own menu, last checked July 27, 2026. Something off? Tell us.
Nothing else pouring cheap in Upper West Side right now.
430 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024 · Directions
