Cheapest on the menu · $25 The Nutty Irish Man
Diner 24 NYC
Gramercy283 3rd Ave
4.8 ★ on Google, 8,369 reviews
Drink prices at Diner 24 NYC
No happy hour at Diner 24 NYC, as far as we can find. Cocktails is $25, off the regular menu, checked August 9, 2026.
Beverages
Egg Cream$9
Root Beer Float$12
Make Your Own Milkshake
Make Your Own Milkshake$14
Specialty Milkshakes
Snickers Shake$16
Mint White Chocolate Shake$16
Banana Cream Pie Shake$17
Heath Bar Shake$17
Butterfinger Chocolate Ice Cream Shake$17
Vegan Shake$17
Oreo S'mores Shake$19
Reese's Peanut Butter Shake$19
Blackout Shake$20
Black & White Cookie Shake$21
Cotton Candy Celebration Shake$21
Apple "Crumb" Shake$23
"Cake Pop" Brownie Shake$23
Candied Bacon Brownie Shake$23
Cinnamon Shake$23
Peanut Butter Brownie Cheesecake Shake$24
Red Velvet Cake Shake$24
Carrot Cake Shake$25
Birthday Shake$25
The Napoleon Shake$25
Salted Pretzel Shake$25
Cookie Dough Shake$25
The Nutty Irish Man$25
The Baklava Shake$25
Boozy Creamsicle Milkshake$25
Boozy Red Wine Milkshake$25
Prices from Diner 24 NYC's own menu, checked August 9, 2026. Something off? Tell us.
